39/33
Both of them had Julianne Moore in mind
Tale
Ingrid and Martha were close friends in their youth, when they worked together at the same magazine. After years of being out of touch, they met again in an extreme but strangely sweet situation.. When Pedro Almodóvar sent Tilda Swinton the script, he asked her who should play Ingrid.
The answer, alas: it's disappointing
Featured in The 7PM Project: Episode dated 8 September 2024 (2024). I was curious to see what Pedro Almodóvar would do differently in his first non-Spanish-language film, built around two of the most talented actors working today. There are many ways in which "The Room Next Door" lacks what makes Almodóvar's work so distinctive – the spontaneity, the sense of improvisation, the comic timing, the fizzy ensemble work — but this film's main fault, as I see it, is that it' ;s just plain overwritten, something that is rare in his previous work.The screenplay (which he is credited with writing) was adapted from a novel by Sigrid Nunez that I have not read, but it sounds like vast swatches of the dialogue were lifted verbatim from it, with much that is ponderous and stilted, slowing down and emptying the film, where Almodóvar's work is usually characterized by lapidary dialogues and madcap forward movement, plunging you into the characters' world with little exposition – as a viewer, you are kind of just there, hanging on for dear life, and figuring out relationships and social context as you go, grabbing at what you can.
Little is left to our imaginations
Even in films that deal with dark subjects ("Pain and Glory" or "Bad Education" come to mind), the action and its background unfold in convincing ways (even when these are actually crazy if you stop and think about them) that draws on our intuition and empathy and depends only marginally on extended expository narration.Here, it is the opposite: the characters talk and explain on and on, with a few awkward flashbacks to establish context. So, while some of the usual Almodóvarian hallmarks are there, particularly in the exquisite use of saturated, cunningly coordinated color and in the tastefulness of many of the sets and costumes (here with lots of lovely still lifes of flowers and fruits), these are reduced to props – they don't serve to tell the story and overwhelm you into accepting the reality of his crazily artificial visual worlds in the way they do in most of his films. And the computer-generated backdrops of New York feel completely artificial and thus become meaningless.
But the wordiness of this screenplay undermines Swinton, in particular
Almodóvar's films certainly have plots, often quite convoluted (which is part of the fun), but they don't feel plot-driven, even when they are. "The Room Next Door", on the other hand, is all about its plot, and it is the weaker for it.With talents like Tilda Swinton and Julianne Moore (plus the estimable John Turturro) in front of the camera, there is to be, and are, some great, often very moving, moments – how could there not be, especially given the plot's central premise and the way it both reinforces and strains a longstanding , close friendship in its final days? Her awesome strength lies in her powerful, enigmatic presence and in her understatement.
The relationship between the two is subtle, shifting, complex, rich and involving – and yet so little of that is based on explicit dialogue
In my unscientific assay, she speaks as much dialogue here as she has done in at least the last three or four of her films (the ones I've seen, that is) combined. Think of her stunning performances in another fairly recent film about the fraught relationship between two women, "The Eternal Daughter" (2022), in which she plays, devastatingly, both an aging mother and her middle-aged daughter.